BUYING ANOTHER BOAT---TAXES?

B BARKER

Active Member
Apr 20, 2014
233
TENNESSEE RIVER- CLIFTON,TN
Boat Info
1974 CENTURY ARABIAN 454 CRUSADER MARINE V-DRIVE.. ALSO 1987 SEA RAY 390 EXPRESS CRUISER..
Engines
454 MERCRUISER 340 INBOARDS
Say I sell my boat for 50,000 and I'm buying one for 95,000 I put the 50,000 back in to the 95,000 which leaves 45,000 do I pay taxes on the 95,000 or can I pay taxes on the 45,000 ? I'm in Tennessee by the way if that even matters also going out of state to buy new boat.....
 
You should check with the state of Tennessee since it varies by state. Here in Taxacusetts, they charge the sales tax based on the sale price on the bill of sale. The taxman cometh!
 
Say I sell my boat for 50,000 and I'm buying one for 95,000 I put the 50,000 back in to the 95,000 which leaves 45,000 do I pay taxes on the 95,000 or can I pay taxes on the 45,000 ? I'm in Tennessee by the way if that even matters also going out of state to buy new boat.....
Assuming you have no capital gains on your sale and haven't depreciated it as part of a business then you have no federal tax obligation on the monies received from the sale. For something like your state's sales tax or luxury tax then that is based upon the contract sales price at the time of registration (at least in Florida). There have been multiple litigation cases regarding dual taxation where you already paid sales tax on the 50K but lost in interpretation that the tax is on the purchased item not on the monies. In Florida they used to impose an "impact fee" when you moved from out of state and bringing a vehicle in but that was defeated in court and those fees were returned; without interest BTW.
 
In Washington State you are only taxed on the difference if you purchase with in a certain time frame IE trade in with a brokerage. Depending on the magnitude of the money involved, buying an LLC boat does in many cases save the sales taxes but then you have an LLC to manage not to mention the legal fees associated with the LLC transfer. I just did that on my 506 and saved $25,000 but it will cost $in the future. I am now researching the dissolution of the LLC and its tax ramifications if any.
The other thing, at least in CA is when the county calculates the personal property tax that is owed annually, they use the entire sales contract total including the fees and sales taxes paid! Pay $200,000 for a boat and you are taxed at 1.25% on $220,000. They use some standard depreciation schedule each subsequent tax year for calculating your taxes.
On a side note, I just heard of the latest IQ test score comparisons for the 50 states. California was 48! Vermont was 1st.
Still scratching my head on that:rolleyes:
 
Here in Taxachusetts I'm into it for 6.25% of the sale price. Plus I have to pay excise tax to the city where I keep it. Why am I still here again ?????
 
You should check with the state of Tennessee since it varies by state. Here in Taxacusetts, they charge the sales tax based on the sale price on the bill of sale. The taxman cometh!
Unless you trade it in at a dealer. Then it's the difference. That's if something hasn't changed since I last registered in Mass.
 
In Florida they used to impose an "impact fee" when you moved from out of state and bringing a vehicle in but that was defeated in court and those fees were returned; without interest BTW.
That was so messed up. If you owned a car and transferred the reg to Florida you had to pay a $375 Impact Fee. I remember getting it back at least.
 
Here in Taxachusetts I'm into it for 6.25% of the sale price. Plus I have to pay excise tax to the city where I keep it. Why am I still here again ?????
I feel your pain. Some of my friends keep their boats in RI just for that reason. No sales tax on boats in RI but I just like the boating too much here to do that.
 
NY State caps you out at just under $20k in tax. So after the first $230k it is a flat fee.
 
Last edited:
NY State caps you out at just under $20k in tax. So after the first $230k it is a flat fee.
That’s one the effed up parts so some spends 1 mil on a boat and pays 20k in tax while another guy buys 110k for a boat and pays 10k in tax. Doesn’t seem right. Along with the ny state collecting a sales tax every time the boat changes hand.
 
That’s one the effed up parts so some spends 1 mil on a boat and pays 20k in tax while another guy buys 110k for a boat and pays 10k in tax. Doesn’t seem right. Along with the ny state collecting a sales tax every time the boat changes hand.

I know Florida has a similar tax structure. Not opining on 'fair' or not but I believe prior to NY doing this many larger boats were registered out of state with zero dollars flowing into state coffers.
Something better than nothing...
 
NC has no sales tax on used boats, but we do have a personal property tax every year that varies by county. Each state will get their money, they just do it differently.
 
You should check with the state of Tennessee since it varies by state. Here in Taxacusetts, they charge the sales tax based on the sale price on the bill of sale. The taxman cometh!

While that’s accurate, it’s incomplete. In Mass if you buy the boat through a dealer’s inventory and trade/sell your boat as part of the transaction (on the sales contract), the sales tax is based on the net value (sales price) of the new less the value (trade in allowance) of your old boat. The location of the selling dealer isn’t relavant.
 
While that’s accurate, it’s incomplete. In Mass if you buy the boat through a dealer’s inventory and trade/sell your boat as part of the transaction (on the sales contract), the sales tax is based on the net value (sales price) of the new less the value (trade in allowance) of your old boat. The location of the selling dealer isn’t relavant.

Thanks Henry I didn't know that.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
113,162
Messages
1,427,570
Members
61,071
Latest member
TellurideBoater
Back
Top