Dealership Service Advice

OllieC

Well-Known Member
SILVER Sponsor
Mar 11, 2013
6,904
N.W. ‘Sconnie
Boat Info
Sara Belle
2005 Weekender 215
Engines
Mercruiser 5.0 mpi, Bravo III
I’m hoping to get some advice from you fellow Sea Ray’ers on what my next steps should be. I’m having issues with a Ford dealership and them getting my truck back from service. Sorry about the long post but it’s been 3 months and I’m at my wits-end.

I have a 2011 F150 Super Crew FX4 with the 1st Gen Ecoboost. My 1st new truck I purchased for my 1st new Sea Ray. It’s ran great over the past decade with just a few small service issues. Currently I winterize it and mainly use it for the boat in the Summer. It’s clean and only has 117k.

As some of you may know, we moved away from the disaster called Minneapolis/St Paul. In doing so we used the truck to haul household items back and forth to the new home we purchased in September. Truck handled as expected and made me appreciate owning one.

After a few weeks of moving into our new home, I noticed a gas smell whenever I parked, even though the truck still ran great. There is a local Ford dealership in the area and I wanted to bring the truck have them do an oil change (I usually do myself but no time with the move), so I thought they could look into the gas smell.

While there, I basically gave them my credit card. I asked to find the gas smell, clean the valves and fuel system, change the oil, they recommended changing the spark plugs, and I said go through the rest of the truck and let me know if there’s anything else. They called back a few days later and said they recommended the front struts be replaced because one was leaking, rotors and pads be replaced in the front, and that the 4wD hub wasn’t locking on the drivers side and to replace that as well. They said that the PCV valve had been stuck and that was probably where the gas smell came from and I would want to replace that. I said ‘great’, okay.

It was like you’d expect, the service manager stayed in touch but it took a few weeks to get some parts in. They called after complete and I went to pay and pick it up……then it went downhill.

After paying they gave me the keys. It was really cold out and we had some of our first snow on the ground. I went to start it and I heard what sounded like grinding, then when it warmed up a little it sounded like a diesel with a 4” muffler on it. I drove it directly back to their garage. The manager apologized profusely, took it to the back, and said it looked to be a hose that wasn’t in place. He said he’d like to keep it for a couple days and that he’d call me to come get it. After 1.5 weeks, because I never received a call, I started calling. They were not returning my calls. After week 3, I drove up there.

The service manager apologized and said he had been sick for two weeks and didn’t get a chance to call me back, and that I probably could have taken the truck home the day I left it there. However, the truck is in the back lot buried in snow so they’ll have to dig it out and asked if I could come back the next day. So I did.

The next day they gave me the keys, I started it and “phew”, all sounds good. I drive it out of the lot and then once I add throttle, the truck starts hesitating hard, like it’s missing. WTF?! So I turn around and back in the garage. I ask “Do you guys even test drive your repairs?!” ….more apologies…so I take them out for a ride, twice, and were able to replicate it. They also brought their head mechanic with.

They asked to keep it again. I explain to them that we’re in month two already and that it was ridiculous that no one could call me and that no one would return my calls. I said that I don’t need the truck because I have other vehicles but I do want to wash it and tuck it away for the Winter. More apologies…….

So here we are 3.5 weeks later….guess what - no phone calls. I called last Wednesday and told them this is absolutely ridiculous and I’ve been more than patient. The SM had said they wanted to replace some vacuum hoses and should have it done by Friday and would call me back….No call. So I called Monday morning …No call back. Then I called yesterday and got someone who got me to the SM.

9:00am“Yeah, we replaced the hoses and it seems to be running okay now. We have tech driving it around so you should be able to pick it up this afternoon.”

1:00pm (while I’m in a meeting). Voice Mail - “Well the tech said it might be still hesitating so we need to look into it more”

2:00pm - “Could you come to the dealership and we’ll take it for a drive and see if it’s still happening?”

At 3pm I show up and we go for a drive. It’s worse than it was and hesitating harder……more apologies and I’m pissed. He wants to keep it again and promised to call me today.

I told him, again, the truck ran fine before it came here with the exception of the gas smell. Did you put in crappy spark plugs - are they not gapped properly - did you get crud in the cylinders when cleaning the fuel system? It’s something “you” did. He claims they went over all of that and determined it wasn’t those issues.

Sorry about the long post, misspellings and punctuation (typing this on my phone), but I’d like to know your thoughts on what I should do now? It’s pretty clear these clowns don’t know what to do, and can care less about the truck now that I’ve already paid. It frustrates me because I have no confidence that my truck will be running properly and maybe cause something catastrophic down the road. The reason I decided to pay more at the dealership was for connivence and they’re supposedly factory certified with OEM warranties - please don't flame me for doing so, that can be different thread.

Thanks
Ollie
 
Have you reached out directly to Ford customer service? It sounds like someone who worked on it hacked it up. At this point you have been patient and reasonable. It sounds like it is time to advance your experience up the food chain to corporate.
 
Try getting to the GM of the dealership. They fd something up and need to go back thru everything to fix it. A complete redo of their work.
 
Try getting to the GM of the dealership. They fd something up and need to go back thru everything to fix it. A complete redo of their work.


This exactly.

I am so thankful I can do all my own work for this very reason. I have seen more vehicles screwed up by mechanics. Very few actual technicians any more. We used to shame the parts changers out of the business a few decades ago. It seems many have gotten through today. Good luck with the vehicle. Maybe ask some locals for a good recommendation for a local private garage if you get no where. You should also not be paying for their education. Maybe even the f150 forum might have a local expert .
 
Have you reached out directly to Ford customer service? It sounds like someone who worked on it hacked it up. At this point you have been patient and reasonable. It sounds like it is time to advance your experience up the food chain to corporate.
I mentioned this to the SM and may be an option if this isn't resolved by the end of this week.
 
Just got a call and they supposedly tripped a code, so hopefully this will get resolved. Figures after I just typed out a full biography on CSR.
 
Geez, I was getting mad reading your post. You are more patient than me.

Yeah, I would take it up a few levels at this point. This recently happened to me with NTB and some bad Continental tires, two sets of 4 new ones. I had to go up the food chain to get is resolved, and finally get the Michelins I originally asked for. And they have effed it up a few times since; two times leaving me without the SUV for many days because of poor planning on their side. In the end I entered a complaint on their website, which got all kinds of attention as well.

Good luck
 
I don’t know dick about diesel. I will say, I never ever conduct bidness ya bidness on phone. Too easy for them to lie and blow you off. I would go EVERY day in person and be the biggest asshole they ever met. I got real good at it after 70 years.
Just went thru it with my little Suzuki. Took to dealer 11/3. I got it back this week. Got tired of this and that reason for 2 months. Finally I was there every morning at open, “What is going on with my motor !”. Ya they moved it to top of list to get rid of me.
Being an asshole works!
 
Just got off the phone with them and now they’re claiming it’s the timing chain and tensioners. This is a problem with my year, however I’m not confident in these numb skulls. Not only that, he said it would be $3k to do it. I looked it up and the parts are roughly $400-$600. They’ll need to replace some valve cover gaskets and reseal the cover. It’s an 8 hr job I’m reading. They said they would tear it down to verify it for free….so where TF does the $3k come in. Half the job is tearing it down. $600 per hour??
 
Just got off the phone with them and now they’re claiming it’s the timing chain and tensioners. This is a problem with my year, however I’m not confident in these numb skulls. Not only that, he said it would be $3k to do it. I looked it up and the parts are roughly $400-$600. They’ll need to replace some valve cover gaskets and reseal the cover. It’s an 8 hr job I’m reading. They said they would tear it down to verify it for free….so where TF does the $3k come in. Half the job is tearing it down. $600 per hour??


Seems strange it was not acting up before? I would not have much confidence either.
 
I would be skeptical but independently verify. A timing chain doesn’t suddenly stretch. If a tensioner broke that could just be bad timing. (No pun intended.)
 
I would be skeptical but independently verify. A timing chain doesn’t suddenly stretch. If a tensioner broke that could just be bad timing. (No pun intended.)


Or it could be they were beating the shit out of it trying to solve other issues they created early on.
 
1.) Go visit GM in person. Just walk in his office, do not call, no appointment.
2.) Inform him that depending on how he handles this right now, you will proceed to the owner of the dealership and Ford
3.) You want a 2023 loaner
4.) You only will pay for original service items, no add ons
5.) Understand they are gouging you and their techs are morons
6.) If they don't resolve the issues in 3 days you want them to transport the truck to another Ford dealer on their dime
7.) If #6, you will not pay a dime for any service items
8.) Ask the GM right then and there what his plan is, right now or you're moving to #2 right there in front of him.

Post back
 
Could have used the wrong weight oil or did not fill it properly,. I had a 2017 f 150 and had timing chains done 2 times. Have them fix it and fix it right, then dispute it on the credit card and go from there. Or take to a different dealer and dispute the bill from the first shop
 
Just got off the phone with them and now they’re claiming it’s the timing chain and tensioners. This is a problem with my year, however I’m not confident in these numb skulls. Not only that, he said it would be $3k to do it. I looked it up and the parts are roughly $400-$600. They’ll need to replace some valve cover gaskets and reseal the cover. It’s an 8 hr job I’m reading. They said they would tear it down to verify it for free….so where TF does the $3k come in. Half the job is tearing it down. $600 per hour??
Something smells there. Between my wife and my son we have had 3 timing chains replaced. Mazdas (Ford motors). My wife had the 3.7L and it was $1,400.
 
I wouldn't pay shit, it was fine when you brought it in. If they did not notate any issues with the truck in writing they own it
 
One thing I would be worried about is the original complaint you had when you got it back the first time. You said, "I went to start it and I heard what sounded like grinding, then when it warmed up a little it sounded like a diesel with a 4” muffler on it". This sounds to me like a lubrication issue, like if they drained the oil and didn't refill it. Their tech has every reason to lie about it if that was indeed what happened. I sincerely hope this is not the case.
 
How'd they clean the valves?
I don’t know. I know they weren’t walnut blasted or anything. It was their fuel line cleaning service and they said it cleaned the valves. At this point it’s over. I grabbed the truck yesterday and it’s going somewhere else.
 
I’m taking it to a more reputable dealership in the area. When I had a discussion with the service manager at the new place, he was speaking my language and seemed to know what was going on without hesitation. It’s about a $2k job to replace the timing chain and lobes, not $3k like theses other mistakes I took it too.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
113,171
Messages
1,427,815
Members
61,081
Latest member
Agent360
Back
Top